The government is pinning its hopes for the future on growth, meaning economic growth. Why is this so important?
Going for growth is the get-out-of-jail-free card for governments when promises on restricting tax rises have been made, yet expenditure is necessary in certain areas, such as the NHS and defence.
Going for growth suggests a bigger national cake, which, as if by magic, will increase the government’s tax yield and enable it to spend on those necessities without having to annoy sectors of society who view tax not as a duty but as an evil.
Let’s face it: no one likes paying taxes, and we would rather someone else pay it, like the rich and non-doms, who, it seems, enjoy winding up the rest of society by indulging in conspicuous consumption while pleading poverty.
How to increase growth?
How can you increase growth? Until the 1930s, the classical method was free trade, sound money (backed by gold), balanced budgets and the invisible hand of the market, which would direct capital in the most efficient manner. Only it didn’t, and during the First World War, the state had to set priorities because the market couldn’t if Britain wanted to win the war.
After the 1929 Wall Street crash, the US passed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act and increased existing tariffs still further by trying to create fortress America. At the same time, the US banking system called in local and overseas loans, thereby creating a banking crisis in the US and Europe.
Britain clung to the gold standard until 1931, after the second Labour government had collapsed trying to maintain a gold-backed currency. Then Britain put up its own trade barriers under the misnomer of ‘Empire Free Trade’, which had been a pet project in sections of the Tory party since the turn of the 20th century.
Does all this sound eerily like our current state of affairs? Hubris is not a modern pattern of behaviour; we often revisit the stupidities of the past in new ways. Hitler’s actions saved the Western economies from complete destruction, requiring the West to adopt deficit budgeting to pay for rearmament and, to some extent, the New Deal in the US.
Different methodologies, mixed results
The economist JM Keynes had been advocating deficit budgeting and ‘demand management’ to stimulate an economy in a trade depression in various ways, including public works and fiscal stimulations such as tax cuts and lower interest rates. He concluded that injecting cash into an economy would restore confidence and nudge the economy back into growth. He did not suggest endless economic stimulation; at some time, tax would have to be paid for all this stimulation.
By 1979, endless deficit budgeting in the UK ended, and in its place came monetarism. This choked off demand by imposing what today would seem punitive interest rates in a vain bid to control the money supply and led to what some believe was a savage deindustrialisation of Britain. Monetarism fell away because it was like chasing a will-o’-the-wisp in search of monetary stability.
Both Keynesian and monetarist methods have fallen out of favour. Apart from the short-lived spell of Trussonomics (borrowing money to pay for tax cuts, which was meant to stimulate economic growth but instead accomplished only a full-blown money market crisis), all we have left is a managerialist methodology, where governments react to economic events in short-term ways. The Covid pandemic did require expediency to stop the collapse of the economy and the NHS, but as a default option, it leaves much to be desired.
Being in the EU did require some discipline, as budgets were kept in line to some extent by its fiscal rules. Still, following Brexit, we have reverted to our old ways of managing an economy beset with perennial crises over the value of sterling, interest rates and debt of all kinds, not just government debt.
Productivity
One persistent failing of the UK economy is productivity. Before Britain’s post-industrial economic deluge, the output per person on almost everything was below that of other competitive economies, and it still is. Keynes once said that had all the factories in the north been bombed with only their directors still in them, it would have transformed Britain’s competitiveness. The complacency and single-minded determination to extract value rather than invest long-term was in plain sight even in the 1940s.
In 1979, the finger of blame was placed firmly on the trade unions, and there was some truth in this, as days lost to strikes soared. However, the question was never asked why industrial relations in the UK were so bad.
Since then, the trade unions have become but a shadow of their former selves, and the number of days lost to strikes is much lower than it was in 1979. Employers have created the ‘gig economy’, with minimal workers’ rights and the inherent flexibility craved by management.
Poor management
So, why is the economy not booming, with exports soaring thanks to a low pound? I offer two reasons. The first is poor management. A sizeable percentage of managers are not up to the job. They talk a lot about leadership, but there is little evidence for it if we consider the litany of failing projects and services like HS2, the rail franchises, the water industry, outsourced government services, much of local government and the NHS. The flavour of the period is silo management, a blame culture, secrecy, denial and routine apologies phrased as “we have learnt lessons.”
The Grenfell Tower Inquiry illuminated the skulduggery of modern British management. The Grenfell inquiry took four years to detail the awfulness of some areas of British management across industry, government and local government,
The Post Office Inquiry showed what happens when management really goes off the rails and becomes a criminal conspiracy without the organisation.
Chainsaws and car washes
Governments of all kinds have for decades encouraged business investment and had businesses invested to the same extent as those in other parts of the G7, the deindustrialisation of the 1980s might have been ameliorated, if not reversed. Everywhere you look, there is delay, obfuscation and excuses for poor performance. This leads to the second issue, the UK’s productivity problem. What is productivity in practical terms?
This week, I decided to prune some of the trees in our garden. Because I often fall off ladders, I got someone in to do the work. He turned up with a handsaw and proceeded to start. After a short while, it was clear that this method would take hours of hard graft to finish the job. Recently, I purchased a small battery-powered chainsaw and, using that instead, the work was completed in less than half an hour. That’s productivity. Doing the same job more quickly and more efficiently, using less labour.
The second example is car washes. Hand car washes have halved the number of automatic car washes since 2000 (from 9000 down to 4200). This was a backward move. Automatic car washers are more efficient and use less labour and water. But Britain persisted in throwing low-paid staff at a problem that didn’t exist, unlike other parts of Europe.
Can AI help?
Keir Starmer is hoping that AI is going to solve Britain’s productivity problem, but this will only happen if businesses use it wisely. If all they do is create more useless chatbots and seek to dehumanise businesses, then what will happen is more perverse business decisions driven by AI. As the Productivity Institute points out, under-investment, the lack of diffusion of research, and a lack of joined-up policy-making are the root causes behind Britain’s productivity problem.
Growth and productivity are linked, and Britain has a poor record in both areas. The Labour government is proposing spending public money on the energy network to bring down energy costs and increase self-sufficiency producing long-term growth.
Taking on NIMBYs and Keir Starmer promoting AI might help with growth, but only if the government aligns policy-making with the growth and productivity agenda. Too often in the past, governments have indulged in ideologically based policy-making that may not align with making policy for practical growth and productivity.
Elsewhere, the government has productivity and management problems, especially in the NHS. Restructuring local government may help, but it will take time. Whether combined authorities and Mayors will make any difference is yet to be seen.
Brexit has allowed the management and productivity cans to be kicked down the road, but now, from the nettle of decline, we must pluck the flower of humane efficiency. Work needs to be more efficiently carried out and made more pleasant, worthwhile and less bureaucratic. Growth and productivity will improve if AI gives the workforce more autonomy and satisfaction. If all that happens is a tech-driven treadmill, it won’t.






