If you want to court unpopularity, try becoming the chancellor of the exchequer. Being the guardian of the nation’s finances is almost as popular as being the CEO of Southern Water. So far, Rachel Reeves has managed to upset OAPs (winter fuel payments), businesses (raising employer national insurance and minimum wage levels), private schools (VAT) and farmers (inheritance tax). Reeves and Keir Starmer have plans for economic growth, but are they realistic and achievable?
None of these tax rises is that unfair. Businesses have employed low-cost labour for years, and the ‘gig economy’ still thrives with minimal worker rights. Many OAPs will be affected by the withdrawal of winter fuel payments, but the £300 winter fuel allowance only subsidises high energy prices. A policy of national home insulation and financing lower-priced green energy (micro or large scale) would do better by reducing everyone’s energy bills.
UK private school pupils comprise just 6–7% of the total population of school children in Britain, and despite the claims of some in the private school sector, the state sector has not yet been overwhelmed with former private school children.
The farming community is angry, but if the government and the farmers sit down together, we might get reliable data on inheritance tax on farms. Farmers are important, but are they more important than those working in health, the military, or the emergency services? If not, is there any justification for awarding tax exemption to this particular group?
Still, the government has been facing adverse political weather and voter disenchantment, which it has hoped to counteract with policy announcements around its central aim of economic growth.
Labour’s plans for growth
The government faced a stern test with the UK rioters, who were brought onto the streets by deliberate misinformation but also anger at being left behind, with characteristics such as poor social infrastructure, poor housing, poor employment prospects, etc. We are told that growth is the universal cure-all for ‘left behind Britain’. But how do we achieve it?
In a major speech in January, Reeves listed several infrastructure projects, such as building a UK Silicon Valley in the Oxford-Cambridge Arc, investing in the UK wealth fund, and cutting planning and environmental blocks to progress. These, she said, were examples of where growth could be achieved and should be expedited.
So, here in the South East, what does the Rachel Reeves economic growth formula mean on the ground? It means the third runway at Heathrow, expansion at Gatwick, and a second Thames Crossing.
The cost of all this additional infrastructure is eye-watering. Heathrow’s third runway, with its tunnel under the M25, is estimated to cost £14bn+, Gatwick expansion £2.2bn and the second Thames Crossing £9bn. Who will benefit from this airport and road-building expenditure? Will the Gatwick and Heathrow projects give a positive cost-benefit?
Airport expansion – not an unalloyed growth point
We know the downsides: noise, pollution and increased carbon emissions, but what are the upsides? Construction jobs and airport jobs certainly; during the pandemic, restrictions on travel meant that Crawley was gravely impacted.
Apart from this, however, for growth to happen more widely, there will have to be more visitors to Britain than British people flying overseas on holiday. This looks unlikely. According to travel trends in 2023, the Office for National Statistics stated that there were 38 million visits by overseas residents to the UK in 2023, and they spent £31.1bn, both figures up from 2022.
Against this however, British people took 86.2 million trips abroad, spending £72.4bn doing so, again both figures on a rising trend. Therefore, there is a net loss to the economy of £41.3bn, which, funnily enough, is what would be added to the economy by expanding free school meals, but of course, that won’t happen.
Now, we cannot lock people in and stop all foreign travel, as happened in East Germany or North Korea, but it does go to show that airport expansion is not an unalloyed growth point.
New roads have a poor benefit-to-cost ratio
Considering the Lower Thames Crossing, we must allow for the fact that the government has already spent £800mn at the planning stage, and the estimated cost to complete the crossing is £9bn. The road transport lobby and those living in Dartford are keen to see a crossing built. In 2020, a study by the Confederation of British Industry and Oxford Economics found that every £1 spent on UK construction creates £2.92.
However, the Institute of Public Policy Research (IPPR) says that new roads are not the route to prosperity. Their report suggests that the Lower Thames Crossing will actually give a negative return on investment, with a benefit-cost ratio of 0.48 (48p for every £1 invested). This can be bumped up to 1.22 (£1.22 for every £1 invested) if benefits such as journey times are included, but even this is regarded as a poor outcome. The IPPR suggests that negative results are not unusual for road construction, and they give other examples.
On the other hand, public transport, such as better buses, returns £4.55 for each £1. If the government spent £1 on road maintenance, the return would rise to £7.10 for each £1 and, let’s face it, our roads do need more and better maintenance.
According to the IPPR, building new roads does nothing to reduce wealth or income inequality in terms of last summer’s riots and their causes because only 56% of the poorest have access to a car, whereas 85% of the wealthiest do.
The inequitable environmental price of aviation
If we set aside any notional cash benefits, all three projects have serious environmental demerits. For all its electric planes, more efficient engines, and new fuels, the aviation industry still remains an unreformed sector, emitting substantial amounts of carbon.
The House of Commons Audit Committee looked at net zero and the UK aviation sector, concluding that a 2050 target (2040 for domestic aviation) was possible. Still, it expected the government to keep the industry on track. With the billions invested in this industry, failure is not an option, but aviation cannot expect to continue polluting and emitting carbon, leaving the rest of industry and society to make space for the nation to achieve net zero.
Environmentalists are sceptical of this net zero pathway, which is why they object to airport expansion, but the government is bound. The public wishes to fly, and lecturing them on the folly of flying is not going to work.
Currently, the public pays for their airfare and expects the company to sort out emissions problems. But if everyone had a carbon account or quota, the frequent flyers would pay a levy for exceeding that quota. Those who don’t fly often or at all would have an asset that they could monetise within a carbon quota market so that the frequent flyers could buy more carbon credits. It could be a means of transferring wealth from the wealthy to the poorest in society via flying.
Frequent flyers leave a trail of emissions over those living on the flightpath, and those under the flightpath get no recompense for the environmental damage caused by aviation. Quota payments might ameliorate this unfairness.
New roads create new traffic
The road and rail industries are under pressure to achieve zero emissions by 2030, and despite the controversy over electric vehicles, some progress is being made.
However, I have written about the SACTRA report on trunk roads, traffic generation and the Smeed Report on road pricing, which conclusively shows that building more roads only ‘induces’ more traffic, so that even more capacity is demanded.
The Dartford Crossing started as a single tunnel, which then doubled, and a bridge was added, but traffic flows still became congested. The congestion is not total, as suggested by those living in Dartford, but at times it is very vexing. Further upriver, Transport for London will open the Silvertown Tunnel in April, so some immediate relief is possible.
If the government proposes a private finance initiative deal for the Lower Thames Crossing, the user will be paying off the capital cost, interest charges, and profit margin for some time to come. The Dartford Crossing projects were paid off years ago, yet the tolls are still there. It is all very well for the Road Haulage Association and those living in Dartford to demand that the Lower Thames Crossing be built, but they also complain that the Dart charge is unfair and that foreign vehicles avoid paying the charge.
What’s really behind these economically questionable announcements?
I don’t think any of the schemes will be finished by the end of this parliament, and none may have started. The economics of all three projects are open to question, so why are they getting the limelight?
In my view, this is a method the government uses to show that even these delayed projects are not too difficult to implement and that the government can unstick a sclerotic economy.
This government is trying to show that, in its way, it is both quieter and more dynamic than its predecessors. It is probably more totemic of government action than being economically efficient. Only time will tell whether this policy will succeed in creating growth and encouraging a private/public partnership. Still, anything is possible with a large majority and a four-year parliament.







