The Supreme Court of the United States have produced recent rulings in favour of Trump and the DHS’ rigorous immigration campaign, leaving immigrants across the US feeling unsettled and fearful for their future in the country.
The current administration has accelerated efforts to arrest and deport illegal migrants from the US, supported by a massive increase in funding and infrastructure to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). With an increased use of disruptive tactics, including nationwide raids and deportation flights, the federal government has created turmoil for immigrants both legally and illegally living in America.
There has been extensive backlash towards the violent raids, overflowing detention centres and deportation inaccuracies, with people coming together in protests across the country. However, the government’s policies have remained largely unchanged, with mass deportation remaining a priority for Trump and his cabinet.
The Supreme Court is the highest court of appeal in the US, examining cases considering the constitutionality of federal actions, of which the resulting rulings widely impact public policy across America.
Over its last two sessions, the Supreme Court has made landmark rulings in shaping and enabling the administration’s immigration policies, which will be explored in this article.
Noem v Doe (2025) and Mullin v Doe (2026)
Firstly, regarding Temporary Protection Status (TPS), the court has ruled in favour of the executive’s attempts to withdraw certain programmes, thereby removing legal status from thousands of migrants who originally entered the country through lawful pathways.
TPS is a temporary immigration status provided to qualifying applicants from certain countries that are experiencing conditions that make it unsafe for them to return home, which was initiated in November 1990 as part of the Immigration Act of 1990.
In the first case, Noem v Doe (2025), the Supreme Court suspended the lower court’s order, blocking the executive’s changes to certain TPS and categorical parole policies affecting migrants from countries including Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela. As Noem v. Doe was decided on the Supreme Court’s shadow docket, the court’s ruling did not constitute a final decision on the underlying legal questions. However, the latter case of Mullin v Doe formalised the court’s position on TPS, issuing a full merits opinion following briefing and oral argument.
On 25 June 2026, Mullin v Doe overturned a lower court’s decision to block the administration’s move to end TPS for approximately 350,000 Haitians and 4,000 Syrians, terminating the legality of their stay in the US, despite the living conditions in these respective countries remaining poor. Further, the American Immigration Council draws light to the dangers of this ruling in permitting “the Trump administration to return to federal court in other cases and overturn decisions ruling against the termination of TPS for countries such as Venezuela, Somalia, Ethiopia, and others.”
This ruling narrowed the availability of judicial review, strengthening the executive’s position in managing TPS programs (which currently protect around 1.3 million people), creating an unstable future for migrants currently supported by TPS.
Noem v Perdomo (2025)
A second case of 2025, Noem v Perdomo, ruled that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents have the authorisation to detain and question an individual about their immigration status if they have “reasonable suspicion” of illegal status. This considers factors such as language fluency, race, and type of work.
In his concurrence, Kavanaugh references how “immigration stops based on reasonable suspicion of illegal presence have been an important component of US immigration enforcement for decades, across several presidential administrations”, supporting the administration’s use of the named factors in determining potential illegal migrants.

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.
However, endorsing this level of profiling can disrupt entire communities. People feel unsafe and unwelcome, threatened by ICE agents despite often having legal status; creating, as Sotomayor described, a “second-class citizenship”.
“Countless people in the Los Angeles area have been grabbed, thrown to the ground, and handcuffed simply because of their looks, their accents, and the fact they make a living by doing manual labour,” shared a Sotomayor dissent, and this undignified treatment has been allowed to continue across the US by means of an emergency ruling.
Kavanaugh interpreted the dissent’s reference to the violence as outside the scope of the case, which concerned only ICE agents’ use of the named factors. He did not express a view on the immigration enforcement tactics used in the Los Angeles region, leaving his position on those practices unclear.
This case established a new standard for what constitutes ‘reasonable suspicion’ in immigration enforcement, raising concerns for legalising the use of stereotypical factors to identify illegal migrants.
Mullin v Al Otro Lado
The final case of Mullin v Al Otro Lado in June 2026 ruled that people who arrive at the Mexican border cannot apply for asylum until they have crossed the border and physically stepped foot in the US, in accordance with the Immigration and Nationality Act. This again aids Trump’s agenda to reduce net migration into the country, particularly from the Mexican border.
As a result, thousands will remain stranded at the Mexican border, with critics arguing that the decision undermines U.S. obligations under refugee law. On the other hand, supporters believe it rightfully restores executive flexibility to manage border surges, such as those witnessed under the Biden administration, providing sufficient means to control immigration.
In her dissent for Noem v Perdomo, Sotomayor warned of the troubling increase in the courts’ use of shadow dockets, describing a growing “appetite to circumvent the ordinary appellate process and weigh in on important issues”. These unexplained decisions have had a grave impact on immigrants across America, who have been consistently mistreated by the current administration.
These rulings have shifted the constitutional framework for immigration policy in the US, removing legal protections for migrants by disrupting systems such as TPS and the ability to seek asylum. Not only have they affected immigration policy, but these emergency rulings are also destabilising the legal foundations upon which the Supreme Court is built, bypassing due process.
At the heart of it, these rulings have sent a message to migrants in the US that the current system doesn’t support the diversified communities that can be traced back to the US’s foundations. ICE has disrupted cities, caused tragedy in instances such as Minneapolis, and it is clear the courts are constitutionally unable or ideologically unwilling to provide an effective check on the executive’s power.






