We are in a new world now. The new US administration is a revolutionary administration. It seeks to upend the current world order and usher in governments around Europe that are closer to its worldview. Article 5 is dead; long live Article 5.
This is not controversial – look at Elon Musk’s interference in British politics and support for Reform UK. Look at JD Vance’s visit to the AfD last weekend, at the same time as refusing to meet the chancellor (all during an election campaign).
Look at the repetition of Russian talking points and the capitulation over Ukraine.
An underwhelming response from European leaders
What became obvious at the Munich Security Conference last weekend was that European leaders now felt that Article 5 – the collective defence obligation in the NATO treaty – was in sufficient doubt that it could no longer be trusted. The European security architecture of the last 80 years is over.
And yet, the response of the European leaders has been utterly underwhelming, apart from the Danes who are jumping to 3% of GDP being spent on defence. Danish PM Mette Frederiksen was deeply impressive at Munich, and she is clearly going to play a key leadership role going forward in Europe. Ditto President Alexander Stubb (Finland) and PM Donald Tusk (Poland). There are leaders in Europe who get that the world has changed.
The Ukraine peace deal
It’s clear that Ukraine is the most immediate security challenge – it is the crocodile closest to the canoe, so to speak. But the doubt over Article 5 is a problem that affects the whole of Europe, including Ukraine. So, while in principle one might support a European force in Ukraine – including UK troops – there are some issues that need working through first.
PM Keir Starmer has announced that he would consider sending UK troops to Ukraine as part of the Ukraine peace deal. This announcement was no doubt to try to galvanise other European countries into action, as well as to try and hold onto whatever ability the UK has to bridge between the US and Europe. But there are two reasons that this announcement needs more work.
Firstly, the UK armed forces are not in a fit state to sustain a deployment to Ukraine, neither in terms of defence spending nor in the size of our army. And, secondly, the Europeans need to be VERY careful about deploying, say, 150,000 troops to Ukraine.
As a very senior German general said to me over the weekend – ‘fixing’ European troops in Ukraine makes Poland, Finland and the Baltic states much more vulnerable. A peace deal in Ukraine – one which is desired by all – will free up approximately 700,000 battle-hardened Russian troops, and any plan for Ukraine must actually be a plan for European security. So, while peacekeeping troops are important in Ukraine, more resources for the UK military are needed, and a wider strategic lens needs to be taken on European security.
The Euro-Atlantic Treaty Organisation
European leaders should pull their heads out of the sand and recognise that Europe needs a new collective defence mechanism. Let’s call it the Euro-Atlantic Treaty Organisation (EATO). (For example, the UK’s argument that it is going to act as a bridge between Europe and the US is for the birds – this US administration is actively seeking to undermine European security.)
So, who should be in the Euro-Atlantic Treaty Organisation?
- The Nordics (including Denmark), the Baltics, Poland and Ukraine – the frontline states
- Germany, France, and the UK – the big economies and two nuclear powers
- Canada – to help protect the Arctic
- Turkey & Romania – to hold the Black Sea
- Other sensible countries like the Netherlands
EATO would have a mutual defence pact, including a UK/French nuclear umbrella. But it should also go further than NATO. As well as training and doing operations together, these countries should bring their procurement together. Wherever possible, they should only buy their military kit from each other.
The idea of buying American kit after the last week is a non-starter. When you buy military kit you also buy a service package and spare parts for years – the US now can’t be trusted, and so buying military kit from them just creates vulnerabilities.
In any case, increased European defence expenditure spent only in European countries would boost European economies. It’s a no-brainer. There are also some great ideas from the Lib Dems around creating a European-wide Defence Investment Bank that gives us all a way to jointly increase our defence expenditure.
Money and leadership
So, what else does EATO need to work? Money and leadership.
Edward Davey announced on The Today Programme that Lib Dem’s Defence policy is to spend 2.5% of GDP on defence immediately and for the government to convene cross-party talks on getting to 3%. This speaks to the urgency required right now and is well ahead of the other two main UK political parties. Right now, leadership on European security is spending more. Only when you spend more and have more capabilities can you lead in Europe.
Which brings us to my final point around EATO – who is going to lead it? All military organisations need a leader. Which country is going to provide the leader for EATO?
The only two countries that might logically lead it would be Britain and France because of a combination of mindset/strategic culture, size of economies/militaries, and possession of nuclear weapons.
My travels around Europe over the last two weeks speaking to tens of European leaders, officials and generals tell me that Europe wants the UK to step up and lead. “Where is the UK?” they are all asking. At the moment, I don’t see the UK leading when it should. I don’t see it leading on defence spending, and I don’t see it leading in creating a new collective defence architecture in Europe.
Back to Ukraine. If European countries could come together and create something like EATO, then it also solves the Ukraine security guarantee problem.
If, as seems likely, some Ukrainian territory in the East and Crimea continues to be occupied by Russia after a “peace agreement”, then Ukraine becomes like East/West Germany during the Cold War – divided but with the West firmly within EATO.
NATO is dead; long live EATO.







