The former Dairy Crest site on Alexandra Road, Epsom has laid derelict for over a decade. Where the building once stood is now a barren concrete expanse with blue hoarding to protect it from trespassers. The site sits precariously on the corner of a junction known locally as Five Ways which has raised serious concerns over road safety surrounding the planning application for a new Aldi supermarket on the site. The Five Ways junction has been described as “fraught with danger” for both road users and pedestrians.
The former Dairy Crest site sits next to the Old Cottage Hospital GP practice and opposite a Jewson construction and hardware supply yard. It also sits less than 500 metres from a Lidl supermarket which has provoked questions from local residents over whether another budget supermarket is truly needed.
There is no pedestrian crossing and the Five Ways junction is used by children to get to and from various schools in the area. A little over a mile from the junction is St Martin’s CofE primary school in one direction and in the other is Glyn School, a secondary comprehensive, meaning that children from around aged five to 18 are using this junction daily.
The positioning of this new supermarket is likely to lead to more parents driving their children to school for safety reasons. It is worth noting that the catchment area for each of these schools is around 1.5 miles, meaning they are both well within walking distance for pupils. This will inevitably increase the traffic build up, increasing impact that has on the environment, local air quality, and heightening the potential risk for serious road accidents.
More cars, less safety for schoolchildren
Acknowledging that the junction is “far from easy to navigate and potentially dangerous”, the Planning Inspectorate has stipulated that Aldi encourage more people to walk to the supermarket. But how realistic is that truly? Either people will be walking daily to this supermarket – at risk due to the lack of an adequate pedestrian crossing or they will be driving there to do a significant shop, increasing traffic at the junction. The risk of incidents is further compounded due to the absence of lights or a roundabout – with the extra traffic, the margin for driver error is likely to increase. According to the Planning Inspectorate:
“The introduction of the store with its associated vehicular and pedestrian movements would undoubtedly increase the potential for conflict between vehicles and pedestrians. There would be a perception that the risk of collision and harm to vulnerable road users would increase.”
So-called budget supermarkets lend themselves to people doing significant shops every time they visit due to the savings that are made. It is also worth highlighting that, unlike other supermarkets in the area, Aldi does not offer a delivery service either directly or by way of a third party, so the only way in which people will be shopping there is to attend in person.
The proposal states there will be 66 public parking spaces with the other five to six being reserved for private flats. Residents have indicated queues to get into the car park are likely, further jeopardising road safety. Epsom is used as a bypass when there are closures, roadworks or accidents on the M25 near Reigate, which heavily increases the traffic flow through the area.

‘An accident waiting to happen’
Planning permission has been declined twice by Epsom and Ewell Borough Council over safety concerns, yet the government oversight committee has forced them to overturn the decision on appeal. Aldi already has a site in Ewell on the Kingston Road which has led to a significant traffic build up as people queue to get into the somewhat inadequately sized car park – 70 spaces to service the entire store plus the flats above it. The Ewell site was also a bone of contention regarding traffic fears and yet was given permission.
In an area where schools are bursting at the seams, NHS dentists are few and far between, and affordable housing is scarce, one can’t help but wonder whether housing for the borough’s families who are put on endless waiting lists might have been a better proposal for the site.
There is also the impact to smaller local businesses to consider. Just up the road there is a convenience shop that has been there for years. It’s a family run business and is being put at serious risk with the introduction of Aldi – it sits 0.1 miles away from the entrance to the Dairy Crest site.
Kent and Surrey Bylines spoke to several local residents. One, who lives around the corner from the site, stated his disbelief at the proposal, asking “where are the juggernauts going to go, it’s an accident waiting to happen.” Another said, “young children are being put at risk, it’s utter madness and the idea that people will walk to the supermarket to do their shopping is ridiculous – just look at what happened to Lidl down the road”.
Residents overruled despite overwhelming opposition
If the proposed layout is accurate and they are to move the entrance further up the existing road, the fear is that this still won’t negate the issue surrounding the junction. The traffic will still back up and will impact the GP surgery which already struggles with a lack of onsite parking to the point that patients park on the opposite side of a busy road and have to try and cross safely.
The Government Oversight Committee’s decision to override Epsom and Ewell Borough Council’s decision also calls into question the practice of planning permission at the local level. The council made the decision to decline permission on a number of factors – and not once but twice. Of the 70 neighbouring houses, 62 submitted letters of objection. It would appear that, in this case, residents have had very little sway over what happens in their immediate area and that, on a national government level, their concerns have been dismissed, as was the decision of the local council.
Aldi now have three years to start building before the permission expires. Given a decade of sunk cost, one can only assume they will get on with it quickly. The Ewell store took Aldi seven years to get approval, and the completed store was opened 18 months afterwards. It doesn’t look like it will be completed any time soon. As of the date of this article, a month on from Aldi’s successful appeal, there has been no movement at the site.
With an area size of 13 square miles and a population size, as of the 2021 census, just shy of 81,000 people, Epsom and Ewell already boasts 13 supermarkets including: Tesco, Waitrose, Marks and Spencer, Sainsbury’s, Sainsbury’s Local, Tesco Express, Aldi, Lidl, Costcutters and Asda, plus a host of other smaller grocery stores such as Co-Op, Star and multiple other independent run stores. Residents are asking, does the benefit of another competitive supermarket really outweigh the potential risks? One can only hope that the fears they have expressed do not come to fruition.







