Angela Rayner set the cat amongst the local government pigeons by withdrawing some schemes and pausing others. Here in Kent, council leaders took an early opportunity to criticise Rayner by calling the withdrawal and pause process an “Omnishambles”.
Often politicians adopt hyperbole to convey a sense of catastrophe where none exists, but on this occasion, omnishambles is the right word. Here we are less than six months since the announcement of the favoured reorganisation, and now the entire LGR timetable is thrown into doubt.
We should be asking a myriad of questions, such as how “rapid” is a rapid review of the process and will it be put back on track quickly for the 14 areas, including Kent, that have been paused?
This deviation suggests something is very wrong within the Ministry of Housing, Communities, and Local Government (MHCLG); either the political leadership or secretariat are at fault, but regardless it is necessary to know what steps are being taken to set this right.
Kent was not accorded priority status for devolution and, again, the reasons given by the MHCLG were unclear with no detailed explanation other than “it was too difficult”. Does this not show that the MHCLG has a problem with accountability and transparency?
What might’ve led to this decision
It is difficult to know from the outside if, after her resignation in 2025, things went to pot at the MHCLG after Angela Rayner’s absence, or whether there is a systemic incompetence problem at the MHCLG.
It is noteworthy that Rayner was reappointed in her old position at the MHCLG, as it is unusual for ministers who left government to be reappointed to the job they left previously, which might point to a problem within the MHCLG.
The governance at the MHCLG is odd as those in charge are not local government specialists. I think this may be the problem. The UK has been plagued with “good chap” appointments to senior posts, with generalists ruling the roost and moving on when either a lack of experience or competence becomes an issue.
However, taking all this into account, we are where we are in this matter. Can we move on and improve on what was previously decided before it was either junked or put on hold/pause?
I think we can. Recently, I took a trip to the North East, and saw a symbol of northerness and hope in the form of the Angel of the North. What, then, can we say about Kent?
If an alien landed in Kent and asked what object symbolised the county, it wouldn’t be Wallinger’s horse, chosen to be Ebbsfleet’s ‘Angel of the South’ – because it was never built. Kent’s symbol would be a hole in the ground – a place where things don’t happen.
The North East has made considerable progress, although there is more to do, but they had the aspiration to do better. In Kent, there is no aspiration – only a fond reminiscence of times past.
Antique roadshow
Kent has an antique form of local government, dating back to 1889 with Kent County Council (KCC), then District Councils in 1974 and, most recently, Medway, a unitary started in 1998.
Along with its antique structure, Kent has policies to match – such as the retention of grammar school education that favours middle-class children over working-class children.
Research produced by Comprehensive Future shows that disadvantaged students are poorly represented at grammar schools, with less than 10% of UK grammar schools having children who receive free school meals, compared to the 30% of children in non-selective schools. Similarly, The Sutton Trust notes the high achievements of grammar schools but points to the lack of social mobility within them.

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.
The KCC’s systemic failings
To solve congestion KCC has prioritised the concrete mixer to create flyovers and freeways for its transport planning policies rather than boosting public transport, active travel, and restricting car use.
In 2023, KCC responded negatively to the announcement of ULEZ and formally called upon the Mayor of London to reverse it. Now we know these zones have since improved children’s lung health in London, yet still KCC opposes ULEZ.
On the topic of health, Kent hospitals are facing criticism for the quality of their care including bed-blocking accusations, describing the delayed discharge of medically fit patients, and systemic failures that have prompted independent inquests. Central government has taken measures to improve the performance of the various hospital trusts, but coordination between hospitals and social services remains challenging.
Overlooking the east
However, the biggest charge against KCC and the Districts is their combined failure to turn around the struggling economies of East Kent, Swale, and North Kent.
Deprivation in these areas has been long-term and deep-rooted, caused by a lack of social mobility, a lack of growth, and austerity – the likes of which has affected the poorer areas of Kent far more than the districts nearing London on Kent’s western boundaries.
Every time KCC wields the axe over services, whether it is libraries, household waste sites, or bus services, East Kent suffers. Operation Brock, a traffic system meant to manage congestion at the port of Dover, impinges on East Kent more than the rest of Kent, and yet nothing is done about it. The Kent Fire and Rescue Service wanted to impose draconian cuts on fire stations’ provisions and only failed due to their board’s refusal. If they had gone ahead, East Kent would have taken the burden of those cuts. It is noticeable that hardly any part of KCC is based in East Kent.
Unitary council reorganisation and devolution are probably the only tools left in the tool kit to improve economic performance that Kent has yet to try. Andy Burnham “pledges growth in every postcode across whole of UK” but it won’t happen in Kent if we rely on the current structures.
It is no surprise that populism in the form of Reform UK has made substantial gains in Kent, probably due to decades of failure to secure growth in those deprived areas. Reform are now finding out for themselves that the current system is deeply flawed, but they seem wedded to a scheme with the least likelihood of success, creating a supersized county council with all the flaws of the current version.
Challenge or opportunity?
Angela Rayner defends the pause to local council overhaul but as I have shown, her defence is unconvincing and poses questions about the effectiveness of Burnham’s government and the Civil Service to deliver change where it is most needed. If Ms Rayner altered the reorganisation in Kent based on the Redcliffe-Maud proposals of 1968 and reduced the number of unitary councils from four to three, or even two, this would strengthen their financial resilience.
If Rayner takes the opportunity to include Kent in the devolution project, it could break the crust of ingrained reaction to change. Devolution could be an exercise in parochialism and inward thinking, but we already get this under the current two-tier council structure. Is it worse than the unthinking centralism from Whitehall or Westminster?
It is a matter of leadership. If the electors choose poor leaders, they will notice quite quickly what happens next door if it has dynamic and forward thinking leadership, compared to their own circumstances. We won’t get “Manchesterism” everywhere, but at the moment few places especially in Kent get that opportunity.
There is very little point in levying council tax if all that happens is less activity on the ground. Too often councils in Kent seem hidebound by tradition, the past, and low aspiration, meaning that whoever is in charge is imprisoned within a system that is unable to confront the challenges of societal change. Austerity has made people react negatively to politicians and authority. There is distrust and a lack of faith in a better future. Reorganisation on its own won’t change that legacy. Reorganisation and devolution might.







